Forgery, Fraud, and Taxes: Inside a Roman Courtroom Drama

Tax fraud isn’t just a modern problem. A recently translated papyrus has revealed a 1,900-year-old Roman court case involving forgery and tax fraud, showing that even in the days of emperors and gladiators, individuals sought ways to cheat the system. While today's tax codes are far more complex, the core issues—fraudulent schemes, legal loopholes, and the authorities' attempts to crack down—remain eerily similar.

So, what can accountants, tax professionals, and business owners learn from history? Let’s dive into this fascinating case and see how it connects to modern tax fraud—and why compliance remains as crucial as ever.

Ancient Rome’s Tax Fraud Scandal: A Trial for the Ages

According to Archaeology Magazine, a newly analyzed papyrus from the second century A.D. details a dramatic Roman court trial centered on a tax fraud and forgery scheme. The document, discovered in Oxyrhynchus, Egypt, reveals that a wealthy man named Petaus was accused of forging tax receipts to avoid financial obligations to the Roman state.—a crime severe enough to warrant trial under the Roman legal system.

At the time, the Roman Empire’s economy depended on a rigid but deeply flawed tax system, which placed significant burdens on landowners, merchants, and ordinary citizens. Taxes were collected on:

• Land and property
  
  
• Commercial transactions
  
  
• Imports and exports
  
  
• Personal income in certain cases

Tax collectors, known as publicani, were privately contracted by the government to collect revenue, leading to widespread abuse, bribery, and extortion. If Petaus falsified documents to avoid paying, he wasn’t alone—tax evasion was so rampant in the empire that historians frequently reference cases of tax riots, organized fraud, and corrupt officials skimming off the top.

Petaus’ trial was no small matter—forgery and tax fraud were taken extremely seriously in ancient Rome. If convicted, he faced harsh penalties ranging from financial ruin to public humiliation or even physical punishment. Unlike today, where tax evaders mostly face fines or potential jail time, Roman justice had fewer safeguards and harsher consequences, particularly for those without political connections.

A System Ripe for Manipulation

Rome’s taxation model relied on tax farming, in which private individuals paid the government upfront for the right to collect taxes. This meant that these tax collectors—often wealthy elites—kept a percentage of the revenue as profit, leading them to overcharge citizens whenever possible. The system was so exploitative that Roman historians like Tacitus described provincial revolts against excessive taxation as a recurring problem.

Some scholars argue that Rome’s financial issues mirror today’s tax debates. According to Walter Scheidel, a much-cited Roman historian at Stanford University, the corruption of Roman tax collection mirrors modern financial loopholes. Just as wealthy elites then manipulated tax laws, today’s billionaires use trusts, offshore accounts, and legal frameworks to minimize tax liability.

Much like modern multinational corporations using legal loopholes to shift profits overseas, wealthy Romans often bribed tax collectors or forged documents—as Petaus allegedly did—to reduce their obligations. This strategy allowed Rome’s elite to retain their fortunes while the middle and lower classes bore the brunt of the financial burden.

Lessons From Ancient Rome for Modern Tax Professionals

While today’s tax system looks vastly different from that of ancient Rome, there are striking parallels between the two eras. In both cases, governments struggled to close loopholes while individuals with enough resources and knowledge found ways to legally (or illegally) dodge taxes. The Roman Empire’s failure to reform its tax system contributed to economic instability, forcing authorities to impose heavier levies on those who couldn’t escape them—a scenario eerily similar to modern concerns over tax fairness.

Some of the parallels between ancient and modern tax fraud include:

• Forged documents vs. falsified deductions – Just as Petaus allegedly forged a tax receipt, today’s tax evaders often submit fraudulent expense claims or inflated charitable donations to lower their taxable income.
  
  
• Bribery and corruption – In Rome, tax collectors often accepted bribes to “look the other way.” In modern times, we see corporate tax avoidance schemes that involve loopholes, shell companies, and offshore accounts to minimize tax liabilities.
  
  
• Harsh enforcement tactics – Roman tax collectors were feared for their aggressive debt collection methods, much like today’s IRS audits and fraud investigations into high-profile individuals.

According to IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel, tax fraud remains one of the biggest revenue drains in the U.S. economy today – something he asserts the IRS is working hard to correct. “Ensuring fairness in the tax system requires ongoing adaptation and enforcement,” said Werfel during a recent congressional hearing. “We are committed to closing gaps that allow some to avoid paying their fair share while ensuring compliance measures are transparent and effective.”

Modern Tax Fraud

Fast forward nearly two millennia, and tax fraud has become a multibillion-dollar industry. From Swiss bank accounts to cryptocurrency-based laundering, financial criminals have evolved—but the goal remains the same: keeping wealth away from tax collectors.

Recent High-Profile Tax Evasion Cases

• Jensen Huang and Billionaire Estate Tax Loopholes: As the New York Times recently detailed, Nvidia’s CEO Jensen Huang has legally structured his wealth to avoid billions in estate taxes through sophisticated trusts. While not outright fraud, these strategies show how the ultra-rich navigate tax codes to minimize payments.
  
  
• Donald Trump’s Tax Returns: After years of legal battles, revelations about Trump’s tax filings in a 2020 New York Times report indicated that he often reported massive losses to offset income, a common but controversial tactic among the wealthy.
  
  
• Credit Suisse Tax Scandal: In January 2025, Reuters reported that the Swiss bank was found guilty of helping clients hide billions from tax authorities, showcasing how international institutions can be complicit in large-scale tax evasion.

While ancient Rome didn’t have forensic accountants or AI-driven fraud detection software, its struggles with tax fraud remain relevant. Here’s what today’s professionals can take away:

1. Fraud Prevention is Timeless

Whether in 150 A.D. or 2025, governments lose revenue due to fraudulent schemes. Accountants and tax preparers must remain vigilant, using technology and compliance strategies to prevent legal and financial risks for their clients.

2. Regulations Will Always Evolve

Just as Rome had to reform its tax collection practices, modern governments constantly update tax laws. Accountants must stay ahead of policy changes—such as the recent IRS funding increases aimed at auditing high-income earners who are not paying their fair share of federal taxes.

The More Things Change…

History has a way of repeating itself. While today’s tax systems are far more complex than Rome’s, the motivations behind fraud remain the same. From ancient papyrus trials to modern-day corporate tax loopholes, the battle between tax authorities and those seeking to evade payments continues.

For accountants and tax professionals, understanding this history isn't just fascinating—it reinforces why compliance, ethics, and staying informed are crucial in an ever-changing financial landscape. Governments will continue to refine tax policies, businesses will look for legal advantages, and bad actors will always attempt to game the system. The role of accountants as trusted advisors is more essential than ever, ensuring that businesses and individuals navigate the tax code fairly and lawfully.

---